I really wanted to love this mascara, especially in black. The product description reads “Provides maximum lift and weightless volume to lashes for hours. Waterproof. Smudgeproof. Gives lustrous dimensional color.” Who wouldn’t be about all those things?

Unfortunately, I found none of those claims to be true. This mascara made my lashes clumpy and spiderlike after just two coats. I even tried seperating my lashes with a comb only to make the whole thing worse.

I have medium lashes. Not too short and not too long. For those with lashes like mine, I do not recommend this mascara.